Skip to Content

Why did China ban Facebook?

Why did China ban Facebook?

Facebook has been blocked in mainland China since 2009. There are a few key reasons why China banned Facebook:

Censorship

The main reason is that the Chinese government wanted to censor Facebook and limit what information its citizens could access. China has a long history of strictly controlling media and online content through its “Great Firewall”. The ruling Chinese Communist Party (CCP) aims to limit potential threats to its power by restricting anything that could potentially destabilize the regime. Social media platforms like Facebook provide a space for citizens to freely share information, organize, and potentially criticize the government, which threatened the CCP’s control.

Back in July 2009, riots broke out in the western region of Xinjiang. These riots were sparked after a violent clash between Uyghur protesters and police forces. The scale of the riots was unprecedented. Authorities blamed the unrest on rioters using the internet to coordinate actions and accused overseas groups of fanning unrest by spreading rumors through sites like Facebook. This resulted in the complete blocking of Facebook and Twitter in China by the Great Firewall.

Since then, the CCP has maintained the ban on Facebook and continues to block many other foreign social media platforms in order to control the flow of information. The CCP justifies this internet censorship as being necessary for protecting national security, social stability, and preventing the spread of dangerous information. However, critics see it as a way for the authoritarian regime to maintain power by suppressing free speech and limiting citizens’ access to information.

Competition

Another key reason is economic competition. The rise of Facebook threatened China’s homegrown internet companies. When Facebook was banned in 2009, it was gaining popularity worldwide and emerging as a global giant in social networking. Yet China already had its own social media platforms like Renren, Weibo, and WeChat gaining traction domestically.

Banning foreign competition allowed China’s technology companies space to capture the massive domestic market and grow with little international competition. Today, WeChat has over 1 billion monthly active users, making it one of the largest messaging/social media apps alongside WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, and Instagram. The flourishing of Chinese social media platforms under the government’s protectionist policies shaped the unique Chinese internet landscape that exists today.

Ideological Differences

There are also fundamental ideological differences between a U.S. company like Facebook and the Chinese government that contribute to the ban. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg said in a 2015 interview that “it’s hard to have a mission of wanting to connect everyone in the world if you leave out the biggest country.” Yet China views Facebook’s mission of openness, transparency and connectivity as conflicting with its authoritarian policies of control and censorship.

China framed the Facebook ban as preserving Chinese cyberspace values. Government officials stated that websites like Facebook presented a threat to Chinese socialist ideals, traditional morals, and harmony. Uncontrolled social media didn’t fit with the CCP’s vision of a tightly regulated internet landscape that it could censor and monitor. opposition and dissent. The free exchange of ideas on Facebook went against the ideologies of the authoritarian state. Banning platforms like Facebook allowed the CCP to reinforce its ideological control.

Trade War Tensions

More recently, the U.S.-China Trade War that started in 2018 led to increased tensions between the two countries. The U.S. government critiqued China’s protectionist trade policies and unfair trade practices as harming American economic interests. In response, President Xi Jinping asserted China would not give into foreign pressure and would strengthen its “cyber sovereignty.”

The Chinese government saw American social media platforms like Facebook as part of a U.S. strategy of using technology and the internet to impose American values and extend its “soft power” globally at the expense of China. Banning Facebook thus became a symbol of resisting American information imperialism and defending Chinese cyberspace sovereignty. The ban reflects China framing American big tech companies as a national security threat used for economic sabotage and spreading Western ideology.

VPN Loophole

Despite the ban, some tech-savvy Chinese internet users access Facebook using Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) to circumvent the Great Firewall’s blocks and browse the internet privately and securely. However, even VPN use faces heavy crackdowns by authorities in China. In 2017, China ordered the country’s three telecommunications companies to completely block access to VPNs by February 2018.

Chinese citzens risk detention or fines if caught using a VPN service. The CCP sees unregulated VPN usage as a loophole that allows Chinese internet users to access foreign platforms and content banned domestically. President Xi urged for stricter management of VPNs to “strengthen cyberspace control and maintain cyber sovereignty.” The CCP continues seeking new ways to patch up the firewall’s vulnerabilities and prevent Chinese citizens from accessing Facebook through VPN workarounds.

Facebook’s Attempts to Re-enter China

As Facebook has saturated most of the global market, China stands out as a massive untapped market for growth with over 900 million internet users. Mark Zuckerberg has expressed strong interest in bringing Facebook back to China. “We want to get to everyone in the world. To do that, we want to have more of a presence in China,” Zuckerberg said in a 2015 interview.

Facebook has made multiple attempts to negotiate with Chinese authorities and charm the government into letting it operate in China. In 2016, Facebook developed a censorship tool that could help a hypothetical Chinese partner company automatically block sensitive posts. This was likely created to convince Chinese regulators to allow Facebook to operate in China by addressing censorship concerns. However, cybersecurity experts criticized this move as breaching Facebook’s responsibilities on human rights and free expression.

Thus far, China has not allowed Facebook to return. Any company wishing to operate within Chinese cyberspace must comply with the CCP’s strict censorship and monitoring policies. The brief moments where it seemed Facebook was making headway re-entering China, like receiving a Chinese business license in 2018, did not ultimately lead to the government lifting the ban.

Conclusion

In summary, China banned Facebook primarily as a means of retaining control over information flows and maintaining the regime’s ideological authority in the face of political threats. National security concerns, economic protectionism, competing political values, and tensions between China and the U.S. have prolonged the ban for over a decade. The CCP continues blocking Facebook as part of its wider strategy to regulate its domestic internet and prevent foreign platforms from undermining the party’s authority. Despite China’s large market size, the government remains unwilling to allow Facebook to operate within its borders unless it complies entirely with Chinese internet regulations and censorship.

Key Facts

Year banned 2009
Primary reason Government censorship and control
Number of internet users in China Over 900 million
Alternatives used WeChat, Weibo, Renren
Government authority Cyberspace Administration of China
VPN usage Illegal but still used to circumvent ban